Skip to content
Acta Diurna Classics

The Legacy of Socrates: and the Timeless Power of the Socratic Method

By Maira Zaidi

The Legacy of Socrates: and the Timeless Power of the Socratic Method

If you’ve ever been asked “why?” one too many times, chances are you’ve experienced what it might have been like to spend an afternoon with the renowned Greek philosopher Socrates. Long before podcasts, lectures, and self-help books encouraged people to think critically, the elderly Athenian thinker wandered the streets asking questions that often left politicians, craftsmen, poets, and even his closest companions reevaluating their deepest beliefs.

Socrates was not one to speak for hours at a time, nor did he ever claim to have all of the answers so far as wisdom was concerned. Instead, he had a remarkable gift for dismantling certainty one question at a time. That's why over two thousand years after his passing, his simple method of asking thought-provoking questions remains an influential teaching method that continues to invoke deep reflection.

Despite having never written a book himself, historians generally agree on knowing a fair deal about the life of Socrates and his philosophy. Most of what we know about his life comes from his students, such as Plato, who, through stimulating dialogues, preserved many of the conversations that made his teacher famous. This, however, leaves researchers with the difficult task of separating the historical Socrates from the literary character in Plato's writings.

Socrates as a man was not what most people today imagine. He was described by contemporaries as short, snub-nosed, and ugly. He went barefoot and cared little about his appearance.

Socrates is famed for his dialektikē, investigation by dialogue. He questioned assumptions about concepts such as piety and courage, systematically analyzing answers to expose contradictions, a process called elenchus. This forced people to rethink their understanding of basic concepts. Called the Socratic method, it remains important worldwide in education, particularly in law schools.

He was born c. 469 BCE. His family was apparently affluent enough to equip him as a hoplite (infantryman). Socrates fought in several battles and was noted for his courage.

His friend Chaerephon visited the Oracle of Apollo at Delphi and asked the Oracle if anyone was wiser than Socrates. The oracle answered “no one.” According to his student Plato, Socrates questioned this claim and began questioning Athenians about what wisdom really was.

Today, scholars classify the philosophers who preceded him as pre-Socratic. Philosophy was never the same. His influence has far outlasted the Greek and Roman world.

During his lifetime, Athens went from glory and empire to disastrous defeat in the Peloponnesian War (431–404 BCE). Sparta imposed severe conditions, followed by a coup establishing a violent junta, the Thirty. They ruled briefly by terror and execution until they were overthrown in 403 BCE. An amnesty followed, but resentments remained. One of the Thirty's leaders was Critias, an associate of Socrates.

Among Athens' wealthy and influential citizens, expensive clothing, physical beauty, and public displays of piety were marks of social standing. Socrates regarded these with contempt. He conversed with people outside the elite, including women and slaves. His followers reveled in his rejection of social conformity. He became what millennia later would be called a guru.

Athens was a city of great pride, and justifiably so. It was a center of democracy, intellectual achievements, and culture. Yet, it was far from perfect. It still had an aristocracy and political class who did not take kindly to criticism or coercion.

In 399 BC, Socrates felt the wrath of exactly this, when he was put on trial under charges of impiety and corrupting the youth of Athens. While these accusations were almost certainly fabricated and influenced by political tensions that had emerged from years of instability within the city, his age-old habit of encouraging young Athenians to challenge authority did little to help his case.

His associations with controversial figures such as Critias and Alcibiades probably contributed to the hostility. The poet Meletus, the tanner Anytus, and the orator Lycon formally accused him. These were capital offenses. In 399 BCE, a jury of about 500 citizens was chosen by lot to try him.

Socrates defended himself rather than employing the usual orator. He probably offended the jury by describing Athens as a large, noble but sluggish horse and himself as a gadfly that kept it awake. Asked what punishment he deserved, Socrates suggested he should receive public meals in the prytaneum, like Olympic winners. The jury was not amused and sentenced him to death. He drank poison hemlock (kōneion), considered a relatively dignified form of execution, and died in prison surrounded by his followers.

His execution has inspired writers and artists ever since. Numerous philosophical movements have claimed Socrates, some strongly disagreeing with one another. The irony is that a man who wrote nothing and professed his own ignorance became one of history's great authorities on wisdom. Claiming his philosophical inheritance conferred a kind of legitimacy.

Everything we know of Socrates comes from others, including the playwright Aristophanes, the soldier-philosopher Xenophon, and especially Plato, his best-known disciple. Separating the historical Socrates from the literary accounts and subsequent interpretations is extremely difficult, a challenge called the Socratic problem. He is often portrayed as a wise martyr rather than a flesh-and-blood man. In 1787, the French painter Jacques-Louis David painted The Death of Socrates, depicting a handsome old man among weeping followers. David's image has greatly influenced how people view Socrates.

In the centuries following his death, different philosophical schools claimed his legacy, including the Cynics and Stoics. The Cynics adopted Socrates' indifference to wealth and social standing to an extreme. The best-known Cynic, Diogenes of Sinope, wandered Athens carrying a lantern in daylight, searching for an honest man. The Stoics, meanwhile, admired Socrates' self-discipline and courage in facing death. Socrates became a model for schools of thought that often disagreed with one another. In his Meditations, the Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius (161–180 CE), himself a Stoic, repeatedly invoked Socrates as a model.

The Renaissance scholar Erasmus admired Socrates and wondered how a pagan outside Christianity could exemplify morality. In 1759, Voltaire published Socrates, portraying the philosopher as a victim of persecution by fanatics. In On Liberty (1859), John Stuart Mill saw Socrates' execution as a warning against suppressing unpopular opinion. In Federalist No. 55, James Madison wrote that Socrates' death illustrated the power of a democratic mob. In Letter from Birmingham Jail, Martin Luther King Jr. cited Socrates as an exemplar of challenging society through nonviolent tension.

Many of the authorities of his day would be appalled to know that 2,500 years later, Socrates is the best-known and most influential Athenian of all time. Perhaps his greatest achievement, and the legacy for which he is most remembered, is that the Socratic Method has never vanished. Today it remains an integral part of academic study, where thoughtful questions have helped people make incredible advances in law, medicine, education, and even psychology.

In an age of unlimited information, yet a lack of wisdom, Socrates reminds us that intelligence begins not with certainty, but with asking the right question.

References: 

Editors, History.com. “Socrates.” https://www.history.com/articles/socrates. https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/s3-euw1-ap-pe-ws4-cws-documents.ri-. prod/9781138936485/instr_biographies/socrates.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Mark, Joshua. “Socrates.” September 2, 2005. World History Encyclopedia. https://www.worldhistory.org/socrates/.

Nails, Debra, and Monoson, S. Sara, “Socrates.” May 26, 2022. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.